Final Research Critique Assignment
For this assignment,
you are required to analyze one research article of your choice from the list
provided below. The analysis will be worth 20% of the final grade.
Of the articles listed below, please choose one for this assignment. Each student will choose their own article, and you must send in this choice to your faculty by Sunday of Week 3. Once your choice is approved by your faculty, it is no longer available for use by other students for this assignment. This means each student submits a critique of a different article for this assignment.
The full-text for each of the articles, located at the end of this grading rubric, is available via databases in the Resnick Library. Once your article choice is approved, you will prepare a 4-5 page paper in APA format. The 4-5 page limit is for text only; it does not include cover page, abstract, and references used in the assignment.
The final paper must
be submitted to Turn It In as well as to the Final Research Critique dropbox. Your assignment is not considered submitted
until it is turned into BOTH places. Failure to submit
to both will result in a non-submission and a zero grade.
Please reply to the following questions in your paper, and separate each one with major headings and subheadings as needed to present an organized paper. Your responses can be 1-3 sentences per question, and all sub-questions should be included.
1. Begin by discussing what the article is
about. What are the research questions that are the basis for this study? What
is the research hypothesis, if it is present. (There may be several, so state
them all.) If there are not research questions and/or a hypothesis, indicate
that is the case and provide your interpretation of what the research question
and hypotheses are. Why is this article important and/or useful to healthcare
2. What is the sample used for this study? Is it a representative sample of the larger population? Is the size appropriate? Why or why not? (2%)
3. Was an instrument used to collect the data? What is it called and who designed it? Were reliability and validity of the measures discussed? If so, do you think they are adequate? Why are the measures of reliability and validity important? (3%)
4. Were there tables or other forms of data displays? Were they understandable? What information and/or analyses from the study did they portray? (2%)
5. If the authors discussed limitations of their statistical methods, what were they? Do you agree with the authors' position? Why or why not? Are there additional methodological or statistical limitations that you identified that the authors did not make note of? If so, what were they? (3%)
6. Comment on the study’s findings (results) and the generalizability of the study’s findings. Why are these results important and who are they generalizable to? If you were to conduct this same study, what, would you do differently to improve the study and its results? (3%)
7. What did you learn about statistical procedures, methodology, and measurement from this article and assignment? (3%)
This paper must be prepared according to APA format. If you require assistance in writing or APA, please contact the Writing Center. You may also refer to the Sample APA Paper for guidance in format. Up to 3% may be deducted for APA errors. The article is to be cited in the reference list at the end of the paper, on a separate page, together with any other sources used and cited in your paper.
NOTE : If you locate an article that is not included on this list that you would like to use for this assignment, please send a .pdf file of the article to me, and I will review it and let you know whether or not it is sufficient to use for this assignment.
NOTE: This paper is due 2359, EST, Sunday week 6